When creationists imagine evolution requires everything to have come from nothing, they really misunderstand what many evolutionists actually believe. There are various evolutionary theories as to how the universe and life came to exist. It may be true that more and more evolutionists believe everything could exist suddenly from nothing without any intelligent input, but others remain unconvinced. Some believe matter has always existed in some form or other. Some can imagine the eternal existence of massive black holes that every so often collide violently and explode into universes that eventually collapse back into other massive black holes waiting another collision to create other universes. Another theory has universes expanding within an ever-increasing vacuum in an infinite expanding cosmos. There is also the possibility that universes come to exist from unbound energies coalescing into matter. What all these evolutionary theories have in common is that they all result in multiverses. With the existence of infinite universes, any argument of fine-tuning becomes a mute point.
If mankind can imagine matter and life originating naturally, what would then motivate anyone to believe in an invisible supernatural being that creates natural worlds? The answer may be as simple as some people not being able to reconcile an eternal natural existence, yet they can imagine some unproven eternal supernatural existence. Certainly the ramifications of infinite universes are profound, but why would we expect anything less from an eternal creator? Would an eternal creator really wait an eternity to suddenly create just one universe?
The intriguing thing about a non-created infinite cosmos with infinite universes is that there must then exist every possible kind of universe infinite times over. There would be infinite universes exactly like ours with people exactly like us living on planets exactly like earth. As incomprehensible as that may be, we can never disprove that possibility. Alternatively, we can believe some omnibenevolent, omnipotent, and omniscient supernatural creator existed eternally in an infinite cosmos and suddenly decided to create a single massive universe and an insignificant planet to test one specially created life-form before deeming them worthy enough to enter into the supernatural realm. Is that really easier to believe?
What creationists fail to understand is that the contention of something coming from nothing is not with scientists that continuously try to understand the possibilities, but rather it is with their own belief of a creator that simply speaks matter into existence. That is truly something from nothing that has no explanation as to how that is possible. Creationists never consider how their invisible creator managed to take nothing and make all the matter in our universe. Moreover, if that creator can easily create a universe, as theists have it, why would that creator only create one? Given the ease of speaking matter into existence, it becomes ludicrous to believe that an eternal and infinitely capable creator would have only created one universe for one special species. It does seem that only self-centered minds can believe that is reasonable. All the while creationists must ignore the prospect that the same mechanism a creator might have used to create something from nothing could be stumbled upon by nature given infinite opportunities.
About the Author
Graduated from WSU with a BSEE. Novice Software Developer. Long time analyst of Biblical doctrines and evolutionary theories.