Roger Scruton is an English philosopher who has published some very readable books about philosophy and God. I own a couple and was pleased to see this blog about scientism… that is, shoddy stuff posing as good science. Personally, I think a lot of science is actually scientism. But because many practitioners with conscious (or unconscious) vested interests have done such a good job in hoodwinking the masses, mine is not a popular opinion.🙂
We are persons, and personality is of our essence.
Flowing from personality, there are concepts that play an organizing role in our experience — concepts like ornament, melody, duty, and freedom — but belong to no scientific theory because they divide up the world in a way that no natural science could countenance. Science tells us a lot about the ordered sequences of pitched sounds; but it tells us nothing about melodies. A melody is not an acoustical but a musical object. And musical objects belong to the purely intentional realm: they are about something else; they are imbued with meaning; they are sounds as we self-conscious beings experience and relate to them. The concept of the person is like the concept of a melody. It features in our way of perceiving and relating to each other, but it does not “carry over” into the science of what we are…
View original post 660 more words